Should Higher Education Equal Lower Premiums? Pennsylvania Thinks So.
Monday, December 29th, 2008
The state of Pennsylvania offers some consolation to people paying expensive student loans, according to Jon Delano from KDKA Pittsburgh, but not for much longer if a state legislator has his way. Pennsylvania auto insurance companies currently offer reduced premiums to those who are better educated. Their justification is that people with more education are better drivers and less likely to make claims for an accident than someone with less education, like a high school dropout. Using that logic, it would make sense to give a rate break to individuals with advanced degrees, much like insurers raise premiums for teenagers because they tend to take more risks when driving, or lower them for married men since getting hitched supposedly calms them down.
However, the chair of the PA House Insurance Committee thinks these policies are discriminatory. Delano says that Representative Tony DeLuca wants to pass a law barring the practice, which I think will be an uphill battle. He points to the exceptions; the Ph.Ds unable to drive for beans and the amazing drivers who never finished the 5th grade. While those outliers do exist, insurance companies make decisions about their policies based on research of the majority’s driving behavior. Not all single males under 25 are reckless drivers, but statistics show that there are enough of them to justify higher premiums for that group.
DeLuca suggests that insurers should focus solely on a person’s individual driving history when figuring out their rates, which is probably best for everyone. It’s a good idea to get multiple auto insurance quotes and compare rates. But in that case, how will new drivers with no history get auto insurance?
(Photo credit: keithreifsnyder under CC 2.0)
