Smart Auto Insurance Blog

California auto insurance companies continue to debate Prop 17.  According to the article “Consumer Advocates, Insurers Battle Over Prop 17″ by Sue Kwon on cbs5.com The Yes on Prop 17 campaign is spending millions in ads to spread their message.

With Prop 17, the clean record discount would follow the driver if they chose to switch companies.  Insurance broker, John Morton, with the Alliance of Insurance Agents and Brokers wants the measure to pass.  He believes it’s a win-win for his clients.  He sees the good driver discount as something a driver should have ownership over regardless of what company they go with.  Morton also thinks Prop 17 will cause companies to compete and drive down California auto insurance quotes.

The Executive Director of the Consumer Federation of California, Richard Holober, believes the opposite will happen.  California auto insurance companies, such as Infinity Auto Insurance, may end up charging more to certain customers including students, military, unemployed, or low-income drivers because they break continuous coverage within 90 days.  This is detrimental to drivers in these groups who may have perfect driving records and otherwise would not get their rates raised on them.

Prop 17 is a proposal on the California ballot sponsored by Mercury Insurance which will allow auto insurance companies to charge many drivers for various reasons.  This includes military people who did not purchase auto insurance while living on base even if they didn’t own a car at the time.  This is according to the article “Nation’s Leading Insurer of Soldiers, USAA, Criticizes Prop 17; VoteVets.org Announce Opposition” found on InsuranceNewsNet’s website.

USAA, which was formed in 1922, says it cannot support the bill because of the negative impact it will have on active duty men and women.  The rating system does not take into consideration the special circumstances of our military men and women and USAA does not feel this is right.  VoteVets.org signed a ballot argument against Prop 17 and they represent 100,000 veterans and military families.

Under Prop 17 drivers, including soldiers serving stateside, who stop driving and did not need insurance for a certain time period would have to pay hundreds more for their auto insurance when they decided to restart the coverage.  Doesn’t seem fair to people who have legitimate reasons to stop carrying insurance for small periods of time, such as the military.